Hey Anna Marie! I'm wearing sz 0 in the toggled coat. I would say it runs small (I typically wear sz 00 in J.Crew and own the Majesty peacoat in 00). The upper arms/shoulder area of the toggled coat is fitted while the torso is boxy. This coat is a lot more casual than the Lady Day, imo... so I don't know if that justifies owning both? ;) But really depends on your lifestyle...

Haha! Sorry to be an enabler ;)

I'm wearing sz 0 and would say this coat runs small (vs. Majesty peacoat in 00 which I find to be TTS). The upper arms/torso area of the coat is fitted while the torso is boxy.

I love the coat. I've also been enamored with the idea of a toggled coat for a couple of years now and haven't been able to find the right one 'til now. Too long, material doesn't feel right, toggles look cheap, etc. Personally I think the shorter length of this coat is perfect with toggles because of the casual vibe. The material is a nice weight and should be sufficient for this area until maybe late Jan? I tried on a few toggled coats in the past where the material was too felt-like -- I'd run my fingers over and bits would float off (not sure if I'm making any sense).